Ex Parte
The Honorable William E. Kennard
Chairman
Federal Communications Commission
1919 M Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20554
Re: WT Docket No. 96-86, Establishment of Rules and
Requirements for Priority Access Service
Dear Chairman Kennard:
Commercial wireless services, particularly cellular and personal communications
services, are becoming more and more important in protecting lives and
responding to emergencies. Private citizens are not alone in recognizing
the value of wireless devices more and more in these situations. Federal
and State governments are increasingly using commercial wireless in public
safety and emergency preparedness situations.
As the President's principal adviser on telecommunications and information
issues and as Chairman of the Federal Wireless Policy Committee (FWPC),
I write today to support the priority access proposals of the National
Communications System now being considered by the Commission in the above-referenced
proceeding(1) and to urge quick action by
the Commission. As you may know, the FWPC is an inter-agency advisory group
established in 1993 to address the opportunities and the problems of Federal
agency users of commercial wireless systems. The FWPC and the Federal Wireless
Users' Forum (FWUF) have helped me develop insights into the ways that
commercial wireless services can be introduced into the Federal sector
and can meet special Federal needs.
Increased use of wireless services by Federal agencies gives those agencies
access to an established and usually reliable means of communications.
Moreover, to the extent that commercial wireless services can meet the
requirements of Federal users, it encourages those users to migrate from
private government systems, thus freeing valuable spectrum for other purposes.
A major impediment to the greater use of commercial wireless services
by Federal agencies is that there is currently no system in place to give
priority access to qualified users in times of public safety or national
security emergency. At such times, completion of a call could be a matter
of life and death. Already we have seen instances in which emergency personnel
have had difficulty communicating in times of disaster. As the National
Communications System reported in its Petition, after the 1995 bombing
of the Alfred P. Murrah Federal Building in Oklahoma City, the public was
asked to stop using cellular phones because local response teams were having
difficulty communicating because of congestion in cellular frequencies.(2)
The NCS cites similar congestion after the Loma Prieta earthquake, Hurricanes
Hugo and Andrew, and the World Trade Center bombing. The inability to get
calls through in times of emergency therefore cannot be viewed as a limited
or isolated problem. With dramatically increased use of cellular, PCS,
and other commercial wireless services by Federal agencies as well as the
public at large, it is only a matter of time until another public disaster
brings this problem to the forefront.
Many Federal agencies represented on the FWPC consider priority access
as a critical feature that needs to be in place before they can expect
to use commercial wireless systems in support of public safety and in emergencies.
The FWPC asked the NCS to take the lead in developing a priority access
system.(3)
The NCS petition asks for a system of priority for available channels,
not preemption of other communications in process. NCS also requests that
the Commission establish priority access as a voluntary service offering
that could be marketed to government and public safety users. This reasoned
approach will let the market guide implementation and should be attempted
now, rather than in the aftermath of a disaster.
While the Commission must address many important issues in this docket,
we urge expeditious action to put such a service in place without delay.
In the meantime, the NCS and the Federal community are poised and waiting
to begin a pilot program on the Federal Wireless Telecommunications Services
contract, administered by the General Services Administration, to answer
many of the questions raised in this Notice. The standards and technologies
are sufficiently mature to begin deployment of this service. The technology
and the policies can, and likely will, be refined with the early experience
with this service.
Thank you for considering these views.
Sincerely,
Larry Irving
cc: Honorable Susan Ness
Honorable Harold W. Furchtgott-Roth
Honorable Michael K. Powell
Honorable Gloria Tristani
1. NTIA previously filed comments on the public safety spectrum aspects of this proceeding. Comments of the National Telecommunications and Information Administration, filed Dec. 24, 1997.
2. Petition for Rulemaking of the National Communications System, files Oct. 19, 1995 at 5.
3. Petition for Rulemaking of the National Communications System, filed Oct. 19, 1995, at 9.