Table of Filtering
Effectiveness Tests Cited in
N2H2 Comments
to the NTIA
|
Test |
Date |
Product |
Effectiveness |
Method |
|
PC Week |
4/7/1995 |
Websense |
Mixed |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
11/7/1995 |
CyberSitter |
Mixed |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
11/7/1995 |
Net Nanny |
Ineffective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
11/7/1995 |
SurfWatch |
Mixed |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Internet World |
9/1/1996 |
Cyber Patrol |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Internet World |
9/1/1996 |
CyberSitter |
Mixed |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Internet World |
9/1/1996 |
InterGo |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Internet World |
9/1/1996 |
Net Nanny |
Ineffective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Internet World |
9/1/1996 |
Net Shepherd |
Mixed |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Internet World |
9/1/1996 |
Specs for Kids |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Internet World |
9/1/1996 |
SurfWatch |
Mixed |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
4/8/1997 |
Cyber Patrol |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
4/8/1997 |
CyberSitter |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
4/8/1997 |
CyberSnoop |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
4/8/1997 |
Net Nanny |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
4/8/1997 |
Rated PG |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
4/8/1997 |
SurfWatch |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
4/8/1997 |
X-Stop |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Consumer Reports |
5/1/1997 |
Cyber Patrol |
Ineffective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Consumer Reports |
5/1/1997 |
CyberSitter |
Ineffective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Consumer Reports |
5/1/1997 |
Net Nanny |
Ineffective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Consumer Reports |
5/1/1997 |
SurfWatch |
Ineffective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
5/6/1997 |
Little Brother |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
5/6/1997 |
ON Guard |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
5/6/1997 |
SmartFilter |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
5/6/1997 |
SurfWatch |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
5/6/1997 |
Websense |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
InfoWorld |
8/18/1997 |
Websense |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC World |
10/1/1997 |
Cyber Patrol |
Mixed |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC World |
10/1/1997 |
CyberSitter |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC World |
10/1/1997 |
Net Nanny |
Mixed |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC World |
10/1/1997 |
Net Shepherd |
Mixed |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC World |
10/1/1997 |
SurfWatch |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Computer Shopper |
11/1/1997 |
CyberSitter |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
MacWorld |
11/1/1997 |
Cyber Patrol |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
MacWorld |
11/1/1997 |
SurfWatch |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
MacWorld |
11/1/1997 |
X-Stop |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Internet Magazine |
12/1/1997 |
Cyber Patrol |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Internet Magazine |
12/1/1997 |
Cyber Snoop |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Internet Magazine |
12/1/1997 |
CyberSitter |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Internet Magazine |
12/1/1997 |
N2H2 |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Internet Magazine |
12/1/1997 |
SafeSurf |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Internet Magazine |
12/1/1997 |
SurfWatch |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Internet Magazine |
12/1/1997 |
Websense |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Internet Magazine |
12/1/1997 |
X-Stop |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
InfoWorld |
2/16/1998 |
Cyber Sentinel |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
3/24/1998 |
Cyber Patrol |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
3/24/1998 |
Cyber Sentinel |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
3/24/1998 |
Cyber Sitter |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
3/24/1998 |
Cyber Snoop |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
3/24/1998 |
Net Nanny |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
3/24/1998 |
SurfWatch |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
3/24/1998 |
Time's Up! |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
3/24/1998 |
WatchDog |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
3/24/1998 |
WebChaperone |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
3/24/1998 |
X-Stop |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Network World |
10/5/1998 |
LittleBrother Pro |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Network World |
10/5/1998 |
NNPro |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Network World |
10/5/1998 |
SOS |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Network World |
10/5/1998 |
SurfWatch |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Network World |
10/5/1998 |
Websense |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Network World |
10/5/1998 |
WizGuard |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
InfoWorld |
11/16/1998 |
SOS Pro |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
5/4/1999 |
Cyber Patrol |
Mixed |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
5/4/1999 |
Little Brother Pro |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
5/4/1999 |
SmartFilter |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
PC Magazine |
5/4/1999 |
Websense |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Biek/Tacoma Lib. |
1/1/2000 |
Cyber Patrol |
Effective |
Log file analysis |
|
Network Computing |
2/7/2000 |
Elron |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Network Computing |
2/7/2000 |
Iprism |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |
|
Network Computing |
2/7/2000 |
Little Brother |
Effective |
Query sample of URLs |