Remarks by Larry Irving
Assistant Secretary for Communications and Information
National Telecommunications and Information Administration
Department of Commerce
at the
National Association of Black Owned Broadcasters' Annual
Meeting
"The Big Chill: Has Minority Ownership Been Put on Ice?"
September 11, 1997
Washington, D.C.
[as prepared]
Today NTIA is releasing its 1997 Minority Commercial Broadcast Ownership
Report, our annual survey of minority media ownership. Our report attempts
to answer the question presented as the theme of NABOB's conference --
"The Big Chill: Has Minority Ownership Been Put on Ice?" Unfortunately,
the report's answer is yes -- indeed, we may have to say that minority
ownership is melting away.
As documented in NTIA's report, this year's numbers reveal an overall
decline in real terms. Our survey found that minorities now own 322
of our nation's 11,475 commercial broadcast stations, down from
350 last year, representing 2.8 percent of total commercial
ownership -- falling from 3.1 percent in 1996. Moreover, the loss
of 28 stations happened when the overall number of commercial broadcasting
stations was increasing by 63 stations.
The specific racial breakdown is as follows: Black ownership represents
1.7 percent; Hispanic ownership represents 1.05 percent,
Asian ownership represents .03 percent and Native American ownership
represents .04 percent. The only category that showed an increase
from last year was the total number of Hispanic-owned stations, which went
up from 115 to 120 stations due to an increase in the number AM
radio stations owned by Hispanics.
I wish I could say that this year's numbers appear to be an aberration.
Unfortunately, a five-year comparison reveals that over the past five years,
the total number of commercial stations has grown by 641, but that
minority ownership totals have declined -- minorities own 8 fewer
stations today than in 1992.
NTIA found that minorities are buying AM stations -- the number of minorities
owning AM stations only went down by 1. It is the FM stations that
are losing their minority owners. FM stations decreased by 27. NTIA
also found that minorities are buying are buying low-power, less profitable
stations. This is a potential problem, as these are the stations that fall
victim to the economic whims and downturns of the marketplace.
The decline in Black ownership can be ascribed in part to the sale of
US Radio, the largest Black-owned broadcast company in the U.S. to Clear
Channel Communications. NTIA also believes that the underrepresentation
of minority owners bears a direct relationship to a lack of access to investment
capital, and the lack of legislation and policy initiatives that promote
minority ownership.
All these numbers and further breakdowns are in NTIA's report. We have
copies here for you today.
I do want to note that NTIA does not have any empirical data to link
the fall in ownership numbers to the Telecommunications Act of 1996. We
are looking into the data to determine the nexus, if any, between the 1996
Act and minority ownership.
I hope you share NTIA's concern about the continuing decline in minority-owned
broadcast companies. NTIA's report discusses two programs that can be of
assistance to minority broadcast businesses. The first, ComTrain, is a
management training program for minority broadcast owners, that is administered
by NTIA's Minority Telecommunications Development Program (MTDP). The broadcasters
that participated in this year's minority ownership survey reported that
ComTrain is the most useful government program designed to assist minority
broadcast owners. The second, the Telecommunications Development Fund (TDF),
was authorized by the 1996 Telecommunications Act to provide a source of
loans and investment capital to small communications businesses. Those
funds are in the process of being made available.
But more importantly, we need to find new and creative ways to address
the dismal numbers. In my opinion, we are not going to have much success
on the legislative front. We have to look to private sector solutions.
One approach is to think about developing a "farm team" -- young,
talented minority men and women who, with the right training and experience,
could be the future station owners. I encourage current minority broadcasters
to develop proteges. There is always going to be churn in the market, but
we all have an interest in preserving a diversity of voices. Another approach
is to improve minorities' access to capital. NTIA has documented the connection
between access to capital and minority ownership, and its importance. Minority
broadcasters need to think about creative financing arrangements and work
with the financial community to increase their lending ability.
In the 1970s and 1980s, there was an underlying presumption that diversity
of ownership and diversity of viewpoint mattered. The declining numbers
suggest that we need a renewed public examination and debate about the
merits of minority ownership and diversity of voice in the media. We need
the nation again to agree on the underlying presumption -- otherwise we
have no hope of increasing these numbers. Policymakers, legislators, and
industry professionals in both the public and private sectors need to think
anew about which tools and methods effectively will increase minority participation
in the broadcast and telecommunications industries
Now is also a good time to think about minority ownership and participation
in telecom more broadly. There is a growing number of ways for people to
get news, entertainment, and information, and a growing number of choices
in the way companies spend their advertising budgets. I encourage you to
explore opportunities presented by new technologies. The Internet is changing
this, and other, industries. A recent Wired magazine article said
that the hip-hop generation increasingly is becoming the "chip hop
generation. Hip-hop and urban contemporary music and video are on the Net.
Most minority owned stations are not. You have the power to change that.
Last week, NTIA hosted a forum on Internet telephony. I was struck by
the lack of minority participation in this new industry at all levels --
virtually no minority entrepreneurs or companies in this field. Internet
telephony is just emerging and loaded with opportunities. Internet telephony
is somewhat a misnomer -- its really voice over IP, with a host of multimedia
applications on the horizon. And the ability to do audio and video streaming
on the Net has opened up new opportunities for broadcasters. Minorities
should be taking advantage of this situation! We must not continue to work
merely with yesterday's tools, but seize the opportunities afforded by
new technologies and their applications.
We've all read a lot about Princess Diana over the last two weeks. An
article by Katherine Graham in the Washington Post on Sunday told about
an interesting exchange between the Princess and Jim Lehrer. Princess Diana
raised the question of how she was going to focus her energies and choose
her causes. Jim Lehrer responded, "Make sure it matters to you. Because
if it doesn't, you cannot make it matter to others."
Greater minority participation in broadcasting, in particular, and in telecommunications and information industries in general, must continue to matter to us. We must continue to champion this cause and make it matter to others. This Administration recognizes the importance of minority broadcast ownership -- President Clinton, Vice President Gore, and Secretary of Commerce William Daley all believe that preserving a diversity of viewpoints on our nation's airwaves is fundamental to the success of our democracy. Please share with us any thoughts and ideas you have about ways to promote minority ownership. Thank you.